Jan 23
Several days ago, I received an email, inviting me to try out the new Vitalist, “perfect for anyone needing to Get Things Done”. I tried it out, asked some questions, saw some feedback, and am now here to tell you about it. The surprising thing is that I haven’t seen anyone else blogging about it, yet. Of course, that might just mean that my stable of blogs doesn’t cover it ;)
Feedback Works
First, let’s start off with why I think you might want to try out Vitalist. To me, the most impressive feature is that its developers listen. When I tried it out, there was one version, costing $9.95/month. I questioned the sense in this, since there are other sites out there (Remember the Milk, Scrybe, Backpack, to name a few) that offer comparable service for nothing. Then, lo and behold, when I went to check out the site today, I noticed that they now have two plans, free and premium. What’s the difference? Well, premium offers a few more bells and whistles, but the free version is quiet adequate for GTD needs.
Another point of feedback I had concerned the inbox. I found it useless, because it only allowed me to fill in the action, due date and notes fields. There was no way to assign a context to the item. In fact, if I wanted to quickly create an action, and I was accidentally in my inbox, I would have to finish creating the inbox item, and then edit it/process it to turn it into an action, so that I could then assign a context. However, I see today that they’ve improved this functionality as well. Now, you can quickly create an inbox item, but on the same form, you have the option of turning it into an action (or someday, or reference). One quick click and you have access to the additional fields.
My Take on Features
Now, you can check out the tour and the feature list yourself. I’m just going to discuss a few of them, and what I like/dislike.
- The interface is quiet pleasant. Nice icons, nice colours, seems smooth. Also, it does allow dragging and dropping, e.g., for sorting actions in a list.
- Designed for the “Getting Things Done” mentality, with inbox, actions, projects, ticklers, somedays, etc.
- Not quite GTD, but you can put a recurrence on actions - this is a feature I don’t often find. Unfortunately, I can’t figure out exactly how the recurrence works. My test, i.e., create an action with a deadline, mark it done, look for an action with a new date, failed. (Note: the help function could use a bit of help itself.)
- Ability to do iCal and RSS feeds, as wells as email and SMS reminders.
- Let’s you keep a separate Waiting For list. Me, I just make a context @waiting, but this is nice too.
- Stores all completed actions, and lets you search through this archive. Strangely enough, you can’t search for something that’s not yet complete. However, I guess the idea would be that you never have that many incomplete actions/ticklers/somedays to look through.
My Beefs
There Can Be Only One
When you’re looking at your action lists, e.g., sorted by context, you’ll see all your actions. If you were to click on “next action”, the list would be filtered. There would be exactly one action per context that’s deemed to be *next*. How do they determine which one is the *next* next action? Why, it’s whatever one is at the top of the list! Fortunately, the drag/drop functionality lets you move things around.
Unfortunately, this paradigm does not match with my view on GTD. I have many next actions, sometimes even for the same project, definitely for the same context. Limiting me to one next action per context is just too, well, limiting. I posed the question to the developer, whose response was
The Next Actions view is a feature that we had several requests for
in our Beta testing. While I can admit it needs some work, it is mainly
there to allow you only to see what you need to do right at that moment
(next), which is why only one action will show up.
Now, if you’re into very sequential processing, this might be for you. But I’m sorry, I have up to a dozen next actions per context in my life. That said, nothing says you have to click on the “next action” button. You could just look at all of your actions, sorted by context.
Someday != Tickler
I love the fact that you can have someday items. I love the fact that you can have an actual tickler. What I don’t love is the fact that they are actually the same thing, it’s just that the tickler has a date. So, if you got to the Someday tab, you’ll see

I’m uncomfortable with marrying somedays and ticklers. To me they are philosophically different. A tickler item is something important, and important on a particular day. A someday item is something that you want to look at every now and then, but it’s guaranteed not to be important *right* now.
Cool Things
In addition to the aforementioned neat features, there are a couple of cool things that I really like.
Keyboard Shortcuts
Mouse be damned - the keyboard rocks. Vitalist has some keyboard shortcuts that you can use to get really fast.

Mobile Edition
Something I noticed today on the feature list was the Mobile Edition to “use Vitalist on your Palm, Windows Mobile, or Blackberry smart phone to stay productive on-the-go”. Hmmmm, and it’s included in the free version. This could be breakthrough technology for me. Let’s look into it.
Oh, there it is. Buried in the help page. “Point your browser to www.vitalist.mobi on your mobile device.” Siiiiiigh. My Palm doesn’t do the Internet. Oh well. The functionality is still cool - that would be the ultimate in ubiquitous capture if you could have it with you all the time.
Premium Version
I’m very pleased that Vitalist is offering a free version, as well as the premium. What might be in the premium that would be worth $9.95/month, you might ask? Well, not having the premium version, I can only give you what’s on the web:
- SSL Encryption
- File Attachments
- Collaboration
- Calendar (coming soon)
The concept of file attachments is very cool, and might be worth the $$$. And a calendar? Well, now we’re talking. I’m always on the lookout for an all-in-one GTD tool that allows me my hard landscape, as well as my lists of NAs, sorted by context and/or project.
Conclusion
I think that Vitalist is setting itself up to be a contender to Scrybe, one of the most-touted new productivity webpages out there right now. Scrybe is not designed to be a GTD tool, although it’s reasonably easy to mash it into the right shape. Vitalist has the potential, when they get their calendar up and running, to beat Scrybe at the GTD game. Of course, it would then cost you $9.95/month; however, who all thinks that Scrybe is going to stay free forever? Show of hands?